Bidwell Home Buyers
How it works Guides FAQ (530) 513-8586 Get my offer

Guides · November 6, 2026 · Tyler Carlisle

How a cash offer is calculated (the math, no mystery number)

A cash offer is not a number someone pulls out of the air. It starts with what the house would sell for after it's fixed, then subtracts what it costs to get it there and sell it again. Here is each step, with an example you can check.

If you've asked a few cash buyers about your house, you may have gotten offers tens of thousands of dollars apart with no explanation. That usually means somebody skipped a step, guessed at repairs, or never planned to close at that price. Once you know how the math works, you can ask the right questions and tell a real offer from a placeholder.

Step 1: After-repair value (ARV)

Everything starts with ARV: what your house should sell for once it's repaired and updated to the standard of the neighborhood. A buyer gets there the same way an appraiser would, by looking at recent sales of similar homes close by. Similar means size, bedrooms and bathrooms, lot, age and condition after repairs.

In Chico, location inside town matters a lot. A sale in the Avenues doesn't tell you much about a house in south Chico, and a house in Forest Ranch or Durham is a different market again. Good comps are recent, nearby, and fixed up. If a buyer won't tell you which sales they used, that's a warning sign. Ask for the addresses.

Step 2: Repair costs

Next comes the cost to take your house from where it is now to the ARV condition. That's a walkthrough, not a guess from photos. A roof, a sewer lateral, electrical panels, foundation work, mold, and dated kitchens and baths are the items that move the number most. Paint, flooring and fixtures add up too.

Two houses with the same ARV can get very different offers because one needs paint and carpet and the other needs a roof and a new main line. Repairs are also where a vague buyer hides room to renegotiate later. "About $40,000 in work" with no breakdown can turn into a price cut after the inspection. Ask for the repair estimate by line item.

Step 3: Holding costs

From the day a buyer closes to the day the fixed house sells, they pay to own it: property taxes, insurance, utilities, and loan or capital costs. Renovations take months, and the house then has to sell. In California, property taxes are prorated in escrow, and the two secured tax installments become delinquent after December 10 and April 10, so the timing of a closing changes who pays what.

Inside Chico city limits, a buyer may also take over the city's RECO energy retrofit at sale instead of you, which is a cost that belongs in this part of the math. Our guide on selling a house as-is in Chico explains how that works.

Step 4: Resale costs

When the fixed house is sold, the buyer pays the costs of that sale: agent commissions, escrow and title fees, and Butte County's documentary transfer tax of $1.10 per $1,000 of the sale price. Those costs come off the ARV too, because the buyer never keeps the full sale price.

Step 5: The buyer's margin

The last line is the buyer's profit. It covers the risk that repairs run over, the market softens, or the house takes longer to sell. Every investor has one. The honest ones show it to you instead of burying it inside a padded repair number.

A worked example (made-up numbers)

Here is how it looks on paper for an imaginary three-bedroom house. These are round numbers for illustration, not a quote and not what your house is worth.

  • After-repair value: $400,000, from three nearby sales of similar fixed-up homes
  • Repairs: −$65,000 (roof, kitchen, flooring, paint, electrical panel)
  • Holding costs: −$12,000 (about five months of taxes, insurance, utilities and financing)
  • Resale costs: −$28,000 (commissions, escrow, title and transfer tax on the resale)
  • Buyer's margin: −$45,000
  • Cash offer: $250,000

Now compare it to listing the same house as it sits. If a retail buyer with a loan would pay $320,000 for it, that looks like $70,000 more. But take out your own commissions and closing costs, any credits the inspection turns into, and the months of payments while it's on the market, and the gap gets smaller. Sometimes listing still wins by a lot. Sometimes it doesn't. The only way to know is to put both nets side by side.

Why some offers are so different

Most gaps between cash offers come from three places. The first is ARV: one buyer used the best sale in the neighborhood, another used the worst. The second is repairs: one walked the house and the other guessed. The third is intent. Some buyers make a high offer to get the house under contract, then cut the price after an inspection, or assign the contract to someone else for a fee. Our guide on cash buyers vs. investors covers how to tell who you're dealing with.

A shortcut you'll hear about is the "70% rule": 70% of ARV minus repairs. It's a quick way for investors to screen deals, but it's a rule of thumb, not a price. It doesn't know your actual taxes, how long your repairs will take, or what it will cost to sell your house again.

Questions to ask any cash buyer

  • Which sales did you use for the after-repair value?
  • What repairs did you count, and how much for each?
  • Who pays escrow, title and transfer tax on my side of the sale?
  • Can this price change after an inspection, and for what reasons?
  • Are you buying the house yourself, or assigning the contract?

Questions people ask

What is ARV in a cash offer?

ARV is after-repair value: what the house should sell for once it is fixed up, based on recent sales of similar homes nearby. Every other number in a cash offer is subtracted from it, so ask any buyer which sales they used.

Do cash buyers use the 70% rule?

Many investors use it as a shortcut: 70% of the after-repair value minus repairs. It is a screening rule, not a price. It ignores the actual holding and resale costs on a specific house, so we write out each cost instead.

Why is a cash offer lower than what my house could list for?

Because the buyer pays for the repairs, the months of taxes, insurance and utilities while the work gets done, the costs of selling it again, and needs a margin for the risk. The offer is what is left after those costs.

See the math on your house

Tell us about the property and we'll walk it, then give you a written offer with the after-repair value, the repairs, the holding and resale costs, and our margin each on its own line. If listing would put more in your pocket, we'll tell you. No fee, no obligation, and you pick the closing date.

Get my cash offer Call (530) 513-8586
Bidwell Home Buyers

We buy houses as-is in Chico and the Northstate.

Contact

  • (530) 513-8586
  • tyler@bidwellhomebuyers.com
  • 575 East Ave, Chico, CA 95926
  • Butte, Yuba, Sutter, Shasta and Sacramento counties

More

  • FAQ
  • Guides
  • Areas we serve
  • Privacy and SMS terms
  • Terms of service
© 2026 Bidwell Consulting LLC, doing business as Bidwell Home Buyers
Call Text Get my offer